Can you actually spot reduce fat?
When I am talking to people about their goals or what they
are wanting to improve on their body I hear a lot of them say, “I want to trim
my belly” or “I want to take away some of the fat from my arms”. Or as one
woman told me the other day, “I want for when I wave my arms, for my arms to
not keep waving back at me.” So we all have an area that we want to work on,
right? Well the question then is, if I work out that specific area like crazy will I zap the fat there? In short: no. But keep reading if you want to learn!
I will start very general and talk about the energy
balance that our body is constantly in. Our body needs energy for everything we
do and we pay for that by spending calories. So anything as basic as
our heart pumping to running a marathon we need energy to complete it. In order
for us to get energy we need to eat and give our body the right nutrients to
pay the price. As we eat, we take in calories that then get used for energy.
This is all well and good if we are staying in an energy balance which means that we are using as many calories as we are taking in.
The next question is how many calories should I take in?
Well our bodies all burn different amounts based on age, weight, and sex. The
calories that we burn just being awake (even if we sat on the couch all day) is called our metabolism. To figure out
how many calories we burn with our metabolism, you can use these equations: (This
is called the Harris-Benedict Formula. Where BMR stands for basal metabolic
rate)
BMR Men= 66 + (6.23 x pounds body weight) + (12.7 x height in inches) - (6.76 x years of age)
BMR Women= 655 + (4.35 x pounds body weight) + (4.7 x height in inches) - (4.7 x years of age)
This is our daily amount burned even if we are sitting on the couch doing nothing. But if we are exercising we can add calories for as much as we exercise. According to bmrcalculator.org we can use this chart to figure out how many calories to take in:
Activity Level
|
Description
|
Formula
|
Low
|
You get little to
no exercise
|
Calories Burned a
Day = BMR x 1.2
|
Light
|
You exercise
lightly (1-3 days per week)
|
Calories Burned a
Day = BMR x 1.375
|
Moderate
|
You exercise
moderately (3-5 days per week)
|
Calories Burned a
Day = BMR x 1.55
|
High
|
You exercise
heavily (6-7 days per week)
|
Calories Burned a
Day = BMR x 1.725
|
Very High
|
You exercise very
heavily (i.e. 2x per day, extra heavy workouts)
|
Calories Burned a
Day = BMR x 1.9
|
The problem comes when we do not use those extra calories
that we take in for exercise. When we eat over our recommended intake [BMR x
exercise] we take those extra calories and store them as fat for later use. One pound
of fat is equal to 3500 calories and so as we put more calories into our bodies
that we end up not using for exercise we slowly accumulate fat. Everyone stores
fat in different ways and places. Men mostly store their fat in their stomach
viscerally (under the muscle and around major organs) and subcutaneously (under
the skin). Women usually store it in their hips, arms, and thighs. So the
question is now, how do we get rid of that fat?
Jim really knows how to burn as few calories as possible!
Consistent training
of specific muscles can increase muscle tone, which can give a slimming
appearance and if hypertrophy (muscles getting bigger) is done a more defined
appearance can appear. However, there is
no evidence that shows fat is mobilized preferentially from the adipose cells
located near active muscles (1). This means that if you are
going out and doing thousands of sit-ups to burn that belly fat, all you are
really doing is making those muscles stronger and more defined. A study done by
Katch et al. (2) tested 13 men on a 27 day training program
that consisted of a total of 5,004 sit-ups. There were no significant changes
that occurred in body fat percentage, skinfold, or girth measurements. There
was a reduction in adipose (fat) cell size but that difference was the same in
the abdominal region as well as the non-exercised gluteal and subscapular
regions. This shows that even if you
work your muscles like crazy you won’t get those six-pack abs right away.
(1) (Plowman, Sharon A, and Denise L. Smith. Exercise Physiology for Health, Fitness, and Performance. Boston: Allyn & Bacon, 2010. Print.
(2) ( Frank I. Katch, Priscilla M. Clarkson, Walter Kroll, Thomas McBride, Anthony Wilcox. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport.Vol. 55, Iss. 3, 1984)
The white areas are fat. |
The reduction of fat is more focused on a whole body
increase in burning calories. Fat is mobilized to be used as fuel for the body
hormonally and hormones circulate to all parts of the body (1). That
means that as you are exercising; your body is taking fat from all different
regions of the body to use as fuel. The best way to get rid of fat then is to
go into a calorie deficit (burn more than you are taking in). This could be
from eating fewer calories than you need, exercising, or a combination of the
two. As you burn calories your body will slowly use the fat from the whole body
which will slowly reduce the amount of fat in one specific area.
So the real way to fight that excess fat that we have is to watch number of calories that we eat and exercise. Good Luck!
Challenge/Tip of the Day:
Everyone has a weak spot when it comes to their diet. Mine is cereal. I LOVE me some cereal and I have a hard time stopping myself when it comes to sugary cereals like Lucky Charms and Fruity Pebbles. These calories are called are called empty calories (calories that provide little or no nutritional value). So my challenge for today is to cut out that one weakness you have ONE time this week. So if you come home from work and just have to have a cookie or a beer, replace that one time this week with an apple or a glass of water respectively. I know it isn't easy but I am right there with you. Once you can make this change one a week you can slowly start to make the healthy choice more often than not and you will save yourself an extra few hundred calories each week! As we talked about above, the best way to reduce fat is to cut down on total calories stored (which can come from reducing calories eaten). This is one great way to start!
NEXT BLOG: PBS and the Most Interesting Muscle in the Body
No comments:
Post a Comment